MJF vs SLS: which nylon 3D printing process should you choose?

How Multi Jet Fusion and selective laser sintering differ in speed, powder reuse, colour, strength and cost, and how to pick one for a nylon part.

By Pranava Fusion engineering team · · 6 min read · MJF, PA 12, Buying guide

For most PA 12 nylon parts, MJF and SLS give similar strength, and the choice comes down to batch size, colour and cost. MJF usually wins on speed, powder reuse and cost per part in full builds, while SLS offers white parts, taller build chambers on some machines and filled nylon grades such as glass, carbon fibre and aluminium-filled powders.

Both are powder bed fusion processes. Both print nylon without supports, and both make parts strong enough for end use. The differences sit in how each layer is fused, and those differences show up in lead time, price and finish.

How each process fuses a layer

Both machines start the same way: a thin layer of nylon powder is spread across a heated bed. What happens next is different.

  • SLS uses a laser to scan the outline and area of each part in the layer and sinter the powder it touches. EOS, an SLS machine maker, notes that the process was developed in the late 1980s.
  • MJF uses inkjet print heads to jet a fusing agent where the part should be and a detailing agent at its edges. A heat source then passes over the whole bed, and only the treated powder melts. HP describes this as one area-wide layer, made in a single pass.

The practical result is that an SLS layer takes longer when it holds more part area, because the laser has more to trace. An MJF layer takes about the same time whether it is nearly empty or full. HP points to this as the reason for its predictable print times.

In both processes the unfused powder supports the parts, so there are no support structures to remove. EOS notes that this loose powder also reduces warping.

Speed, layer thickness and build size

A 2024 study in the journal Materials printed the same PA 12 parts on an HP Jet Fusion 5200 and an EOS P396 and set out the machine data side by side.

MJF (HP Jet Fusion 5200) SLS (EOS P396)
Build volume 380 × 284 × 380 mm 340 × 340 × 600 mm
Layer thickness 0.08 mm 0.12 mm
Energy source Heating lamps Laser
Average power use 12 kW 2.4 kW
Powder refresh (fresh : recycled) 20 : 80 50 : 50
Natural colour Grey White

Two things stand out. MJF lays thinner layers, which helps with fine text and small features. SLS machines can offer a taller chamber, and smaller SLS machines go the other way: Arizona State University lists 60 to 120 micron layers on its compact EOS machine, in a much smaller chamber. Layer thickness and build size depend on the machine, so check the model before comparing quotes.

Cooling also takes time in both. The same study notes that SLS parts stay in the powder cake to cool, and that unpacking can take up to 12 hours. MJF build units also cool before parts are removed, at a separate processing station.

Powder reuse and what it does to cost

Powder is a large part of the cost of a nylon part, and this is where the processes differ most.

In the 2024 study, the MJF powder was run at 20% fresh and 80% recycled, while the SLS PA 12 was run at 50% fresh and 50% recycled. TCT Magazine reported the same 50:50 recommendation for SLS PA 12, and noted that some cost-focused users push the fresh share lower. When half of every refill must be new powder, more used powder ends up as waste.

The Materials study also costed a full production job on both machines. Its figures apply to one product on two specific machines, so treat any such comparison as a direction, not a rule. Real cost depends on how tightly parts are packed, part size and batch size.

Strength and mechanical properties

On strength, the two processes are close, and published studies do not agree on which is ahead.

  • A 2019 study in Additive Manufacturing found SLS PA 12 parts were stiffer, but had lower tensile strength and lower elongation at break than MJF parts.
  • The 2024 Materials study tested parts in five print orientations on each process, and its authors limit their conclusions to the two machines they used.

HP's position is that MJF parts are close to isotropic. In practice, the material grade, machine, settings and the direction of the load all change the numbers. If your part is near its limits, test printed samples in the orientation they will be built, rather than relying on datasheet values.

For PA 12 values on our process, see our PA 12 material page.

Surface, colour and finishing

Natural colour is the most visible difference. SLS PA 12 is usually white, because of the additives in the powder. MJF PA 12 comes out grey.

  • White SLS parts give a light base for dyeing, which helps when colour-coding parts or matching a product.
  • Grey MJF parts are most often dyed black, which gives a deep, even colour. Painting covers other colours.

Raw parts from both processes need finishing. TCT Magazine describes raw SLS parts as having a rough, powdery finish, with bead blasting and dyeing as the most common next steps. We bead blast, dye, smooth or paint MJF parts, depending on how the part will be used.

How to choose

Choose MJF when:

  • You need batches of tens to hundreds of identical parts, where full builds bring the price down.
  • The part has fine features, thin ribs or small text that benefit from 0.08 mm layers.
  • A black or painted finish suits the product.
  • You want short, predictable lead times.

Choose SLS when:

  • You need a white or brightly dyed part straight from the process.
  • The part needs a specific SLS grade, such as a carbon fibre or aluminium-filled nylon.
  • A single part is taller than an MJF chamber allows and cannot be split.

For parts that do not need nylon at all, see our MJF or FDM guide. We run HP Multi Jet Fusion in PA 12 at our unit in Ibrahimpatnam, Hyderabad, with a build volume of 380 × 280 × 380 mm.

Frequently asked questions

Is MJF stronger than SLS? Not reliably. Studies on PA 12 show results close together, with each process ahead on some measures. Grade, machine and print orientation matter more than the process name.

Why are MJF parts grey and SLS parts white? The powders differ. SLS PA 12 powder is usually white because of its additives, while MJF parts come out grey and are most often dyed black.

Which process is cheaper? It depends on the job. MJF can reuse a larger share of used powder, which helps in full builds of small and medium parts. For one large part, the gap can be small.

Can I switch a part from SLS to MJF without redesigning it? Usually, yes. Both are PA 12 powder processes with similar design rules. Check tight tolerances and thin walls, and expect a grey part unless it is dyed or painted.

How do I get an MJF quote? Upload STEP or STL files on our quote page. We reply within 1 to 5 hours on working days, with no minimum order.

Sources

  1. MJF vs SLS: what is the difference? (HP)
  2. Innovative approaches to 3D printing of PA12 forearm orthoses (Zakręcki et al., Materials, 2024)
  3. Selective laser sintering and Multi Jet Fusion: process-induced modification of the raw materials and analyses of parts performance (Additive Manufacturing, 2019, ETH Zurich record)
  4. Selective laser sintering (SLS) (EOS)
  5. The life and times of a selective laser sintering powder (TCT Magazine)
  6. Selective laser sintering (Arizona State University, The Polytechnic School)

Ready to print?

Upload your CAD files and get a quote within hours.